The best diver in Loyola history, Lenhoff ranked 13th on Loyola's all-time points list at the time of her induction. She helped the Greyhounds to a 44-9-1 dual-meet record, two Maryland State championships, and one Tri-State League title. Lenhoff also held all pool and school records at the time of her induction. As a freshman, she qualified for the NCAA Regional, two silver medals at the Tri-State championships, and took two bronze medals at the state meet. In her sophomore year, she finished fourth in the three-meter event and sixth in one-meter diving at the ECAC Championships. She swept the one and three-meter titles at the 1987 Tri-State championships, and finished among the top 12 divers in both events at the ECAC meet. She also placed second in the one-meter event at the College Swim Coaches Athletic Association competition. In her senior season of 1987-88, Lenhoff swept the one and three-meter events at the Tri-State championships and the Maryland state meet.